Comparative Treatment Outcomes for Idiopathic Subglottic Stenosis: 5-Year Update

William S. Tierney; Li Ching Huang; Sheau Chiann Chen; Lynn D. Berry; Catherine Anderson; Milan R. Amin; Michael S. Benninger; Joel H. Blumin; Jonathan M. Bock; Paul C. Bryson; Paul F. Castellanos; Matthew S. Clary; Seth M. Cohen; Brianna K. Crawley; Seth H. Dailey; James J. Daniero; Alessandro de Alarcon; Donald T. Donovan; Eric S. Edell; Dale C. Ekbom; Daniel S. Fink; Ramon A. Franco; Catherine Gaelyn Garrett; Elizabeth A. Guardiani; Alexander T. Hillel; Henry T. Hoffman; Norman D. Hogikyan; Rebecca J. Howell; Michael M. Johns; Jan L. Kasperbauer; Sid M. Khosla; Cheryl Kinnard; Robbi A. Kupfer; Alexander J. Langerman; Robert J. Lentz; Robert R. Lorenz; David G. Lott; Samir S. Makani; Fabien Maldonado; Laura Matrka; Andrew J. McWhorter; Albert L. Merati; Matthew Mori; James L. Netterville; Karla O'Dell; Julina Ongkasuwan; Gregory N. Postma; Lindsay S. Reder; Sarah L. Rohde; Brent E. Richardson; Otis B. Rickman; Clark A. Rosen; Matthew Rohlfing; Michael J. Rutter; Guri S. Sandhu; Joshua S. Schindler; Glenn Todd Schneider; Rupali N. Shah; Andrew G. Sikora; Robert J. Sinard; Marshall E. Smith; Libby J. Smith; Ahmed M.S. Soliman; Sigríður Sveinsdóttir; David Veivers; Sunil P. Verma; Paul M. Weinberger; Philip A. Weissbrod; Christopher T. Wootten; Yu Shyr; David O. Francis; Alexander Gelbard

doi:10.1002/ohn.190

Comparative Treatment Outcomes for Idiopathic Subglottic Stenosis: 5-Year Update

William S. Tierney, Li Ching Huang, Sheau Chiann Chen, Lynn D. Berry, Catherine Anderson, Milan R. Amin, Michael S. Benninger, Joel H. Blumin, Jonathan M. Bock, Paul C. Bryson, Paul F. Castellanos, Matthew S. Clary, Seth M. Cohen, Brianna K. Crawley, Seth H. Dailey, James J. Daniero, Alessandro de Alarcon, Donald T. Donovan, Eric S. Edell, Dale C. EkbomDaniel S. Fink, Ramon A. Franco, Catherine Gaelyn Garrett, Elizabeth A. Guardiani, Alexander T. Hillel, Henry T. Hoffman, Norman D. Hogikyan, Rebecca J. Howell, Michael M. Johns, Jan L. Kasperbauer, Sid M. Khosla, Cheryl Kinnard, Robbi A. Kupfer, Alexander J. Langerman, Robert J. Lentz, Robert R. Lorenz, David G. Lott, Samir S. Makani, Fabien Maldonado, Laura Matrka, Andrew J. McWhorter, Albert L. Merati, Matthew Mori, James L. Netterville, Karla O'Dell, Julina Ongkasuwan, Gregory N. Postma, Lindsay S. Reder, Sarah L. Rohde, Brent E. Richardson, Otis B. Rickman, Clark A. Rosen, Matthew Rohlfing, Michael J. Rutter, Guri S. Sandhu, Joshua S. Schindler, Glenn Todd Schneider, Rupali N. Shah, Andrew G. Sikora, Robert J. Sinard, Marshall E. Smith, Libby J. Smith, Ahmed M.S. Soliman, Sigríður Sveinsdóttir, David Veivers, Sunil P. Verma, Paul M. Weinberger, Philip A. Weissbrod, Christopher T. Wootten, Yu Shyr, David O. Francis, Alexander Gelbard

Research output: Contribution to journal › Article › peer-review

3 Scopus citations

Abstract

The North American Airway Collaborative (NoAAC) previously published a 3-year multi-institutional prospective cohort study showing variation in treatment effectiveness between 3 primary surgical techniques for idiopathic subglottic stenosis (iSGS). In this report, we update these findings to include 5 years of data evaluating treatment effectiveness. Patients in the NoAAC cohort were re-enrolled for 2 additional years and followed using the prespecified published protocol. Consistent with prior data, prospective observation of 487 iSGS patients for 5 years showed treatment effectiveness differed by modality. Cricotracheal resection maintained the lowest rate of recurrent operation (5%), followed by endoscopic resection with adjuvant medical therapy (30%) and endoscopic dilation (50%). These data support the initial observations and continue to provide value to providers and patients navigating longitudinal decision-making. Level of evidence: 2—prospective cohort study.

Original language	English (US)
Pages (from-to)	1570-1575
Number of pages	6
Journal	Otolaryngology - Head and Neck Surgery (United States)
Volume	168
Issue number	6
DOIs	https://doi.org/10.1002/ohn.190
State	Published - Jun 2023
Externally published	Yes

Keywords

cricotracheal
dilation
dyspnea
endoscopic resection
iSGS
idiopathic
laryngology
subglottic stenosis
tracheal resection

ASJC Scopus subject areas

Surgery
Otorhinolaryngology

Access to Document

10.1002/ohn.190

Cite this

Tierney, W. S., Huang, L. C., Chen, S. C., Berry, L. D., Anderson, C., Amin, M. R., Benninger, M. S., Blumin, J. H., Bock, J. M., Bryson, P. C., Castellanos, P. F., Clary, M. S., Cohen, S. M., Crawley, B. K., Dailey, S. H., Daniero, J. J., de Alarcon, A., Donovan, D. T., Edell, E. S., ... Gelbard, A. (2023). Comparative Treatment Outcomes for Idiopathic Subglottic Stenosis: 5-Year Update. Otolaryngology - Head and Neck Surgery (United States), 168(6), 1570-1575. https://doi.org/10.1002/ohn.190

Tierney, WS, Huang, LC, Chen, SC, Berry, LD, Anderson, C, Amin, MR, Benninger, MS, Blumin, JH, Bock, JM, Bryson, PC, Castellanos, PF, Clary, MS, Cohen, SM, Crawley, BK, Dailey, SH, Daniero, JJ, de Alarcon, A, Donovan, DT, Edell, ES, Ekbom, DC, Fink, DS, Franco, RA, Garrett, CG, Guardiani, EA, Hillel, AT, Hoffman, HT, Hogikyan, ND, Howell, RJ, Johns, MM, Kasperbauer, JL, Khosla, SM, Kinnard, C, Kupfer, RA, Langerman, AJ, Lentz, RJ, Lorenz, RR, Lott, DG, Makani, SS, Maldonado, F, Matrka, L, McWhorter, AJ, Merati, AL, Mori, M, Netterville, JL, O'Dell, K, Ongkasuwan, J, Postma, GN, Reder, LS, Rohde, SL, Richardson, BE, Rickman, OB, Rosen, CA, Rohlfing, M, Rutter, MJ, Sandhu, GS, Schindler, JS, Schneider, GT, Shah, RN, Sikora, AG, Sinard, RJ, Smith, ME, Smith, LJ, Soliman, AMS, Sveinsdóttir, S, Veivers, D, Verma, SP, Weinberger, PM, Weissbrod, PA, Wootten, CT, Shyr, Y, Francis, DO & Gelbard, A 2023, 'Comparative Treatment Outcomes for Idiopathic Subglottic Stenosis: 5-Year Update', Otolaryngology - Head and Neck Surgery (United States), vol. 168, no. 6, pp. 1570-1575. https://doi.org/10.1002/ohn.190

@article{29d4bdced48348329fe0db672bd41042,

title = "Comparative Treatment Outcomes for Idiopathic Subglottic Stenosis: 5-Year Update",

abstract = "The North American Airway Collaborative (NoAAC) previously published a 3-year multi-institutional prospective cohort study showing variation in treatment effectiveness between 3 primary surgical techniques for idiopathic subglottic stenosis (iSGS). In this report, we update these findings to include 5 years of data evaluating treatment effectiveness. Patients in the NoAAC cohort were re-enrolled for 2 additional years and followed using the prespecified published protocol. Consistent with prior data, prospective observation of 487 iSGS patients for 5 years showed treatment effectiveness differed by modality. Cricotracheal resection maintained the lowest rate of recurrent operation (5%), followed by endoscopic resection with adjuvant medical therapy (30%) and endoscopic dilation (50%). These data support the initial observations and continue to provide value to providers and patients navigating longitudinal decision-making. Level of evidence: 2—prospective cohort study.",

keywords = "cricotracheal, dilation, dyspnea, endoscopic resection, iSGS, idiopathic, laryngology, subglottic stenosis, tracheal resection",

author = "Tierney, {William S.} and Huang, {Li Ching} and Chen, {Sheau Chiann} and Berry, {Lynn D.} and Catherine Anderson and Amin, {Milan R.} and Benninger, {Michael S.} and Blumin, {Joel H.} and Bock, {Jonathan M.} and Bryson, {Paul C.} and Castellanos, {Paul F.} and Clary, {Matthew S.} and Cohen, {Seth M.} and Crawley, {Brianna K.} and Dailey, {Seth H.} and Daniero, {James J.} and Alessandro de Alarcon and Donovan, {Donald T.} and Edell, {Eric S.} and Ekbom, {Dale C.} and Fink, {Daniel S.} and Franco, {Ramon A.} and Garrett, {Catherine Gaelyn} and Guardiani, {Elizabeth A.} and Hillel, {Alexander T.} and Hoffman, {Henry T.} and Hogikyan, {Norman D.} and Howell, {Rebecca J.} and Johns, {Michael M.} and Kasperbauer, {Jan L.} and Khosla, {Sid M.} and Cheryl Kinnard and Kupfer, {Robbi A.} and Langerman, {Alexander J.} and Lentz, {Robert J.} and Lorenz, {Robert R.} and Lott, {David G.} and Makani, {Samir S.} and Fabien Maldonado and Laura Matrka and McWhorter, {Andrew J.} and Merati, {Albert L.} and Matthew Mori and Netterville, {James L.} and Karla O'Dell and Julina Ongkasuwan and Postma, {Gregory N.} and Reder, {Lindsay S.} and Rohde, {Sarah L.} and Richardson, {Brent E.} and Rickman, {Otis B.} and Rosen, {Clark A.} and Matthew Rohlfing and Rutter, {Michael J.} and Sandhu, {Guri S.} and Schindler, {Joshua S.} and Schneider, {Glenn Todd} and Shah, {Rupali N.} and Sikora, {Andrew G.} and Sinard, {Robert J.} and Smith, {Marshall E.} and Smith, {Libby J.} and Soliman, {Ahmed M.S.} and Sigr{\'i}{\dh}ur Sveinsd{\'o}ttir and David Veivers and Verma, {Sunil P.} and Weinberger, {Paul M.} and Weissbrod, {Philip A.} and Wootten, {Christopher T.} and Yu Shyr and Francis, {David O.} and Alexander Gelbard",

note = "Publisher Copyright: {\textcopyright} 2023 American Academy of Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery Foundation.",

year = "2023",

month = jun,

doi = "10.1002/ohn.190",

language = "English (US)",

volume = "168",

pages = "1570--1575",

journal = "Otolaryngology - Head and Neck Surgery (United States)",

issn = "0194-5998",

publisher = "Mosby Inc.",

number = "6",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Comparative Treatment Outcomes for Idiopathic Subglottic Stenosis

T2 - 5-Year Update

AU - Tierney, William S.

AU - Huang, Li Ching

AU - Chen, Sheau Chiann

AU - Berry, Lynn D.

AU - Anderson, Catherine

AU - Amin, Milan R.

AU - Benninger, Michael S.

AU - Blumin, Joel H.

AU - Bock, Jonathan M.

AU - Bryson, Paul C.

AU - Castellanos, Paul F.

AU - Clary, Matthew S.

AU - Cohen, Seth M.

AU - Crawley, Brianna K.

AU - Dailey, Seth H.

AU - Daniero, James J.

AU - de Alarcon, Alessandro

AU - Donovan, Donald T.

AU - Edell, Eric S.

AU - Ekbom, Dale C.

AU - Fink, Daniel S.

AU - Franco, Ramon A.

AU - Garrett, Catherine Gaelyn

AU - Guardiani, Elizabeth A.

AU - Hillel, Alexander T.

AU - Hoffman, Henry T.

AU - Hogikyan, Norman D.

AU - Howell, Rebecca J.

AU - Johns, Michael M.

AU - Kasperbauer, Jan L.

AU - Khosla, Sid M.

AU - Kinnard, Cheryl

AU - Kupfer, Robbi A.

AU - Langerman, Alexander J.

AU - Lentz, Robert J.

AU - Lorenz, Robert R.

AU - Lott, David G.

AU - Makani, Samir S.

AU - Maldonado, Fabien

AU - Matrka, Laura

AU - McWhorter, Andrew J.

AU - Merati, Albert L.

AU - Mori, Matthew

AU - Netterville, James L.

AU - O'Dell, Karla

AU - Ongkasuwan, Julina

AU - Postma, Gregory N.

AU - Reder, Lindsay S.

AU - Rohde, Sarah L.

AU - Richardson, Brent E.

AU - Rickman, Otis B.

AU - Rosen, Clark A.

AU - Rohlfing, Matthew

AU - Rutter, Michael J.

AU - Sandhu, Guri S.

AU - Schindler, Joshua S.

AU - Schneider, Glenn Todd

AU - Shah, Rupali N.

AU - Sikora, Andrew G.

AU - Sinard, Robert J.

AU - Smith, Marshall E.

AU - Smith, Libby J.

AU - Soliman, Ahmed M.S.

AU - Sveinsdóttir, Sigríður

AU - Veivers, David

AU - Verma, Sunil P.

AU - Weinberger, Paul M.

AU - Weissbrod, Philip A.

AU - Wootten, Christopher T.

AU - Shyr, Yu

AU - Francis, David O.

AU - Gelbard, Alexander

PY - 2023/6

Y1 - 2023/6

N2 - The North American Airway Collaborative (NoAAC) previously published a 3-year multi-institutional prospective cohort study showing variation in treatment effectiveness between 3 primary surgical techniques for idiopathic subglottic stenosis (iSGS). In this report, we update these findings to include 5 years of data evaluating treatment effectiveness. Patients in the NoAAC cohort were re-enrolled for 2 additional years and followed using the prespecified published protocol. Consistent with prior data, prospective observation of 487 iSGS patients for 5 years showed treatment effectiveness differed by modality. Cricotracheal resection maintained the lowest rate of recurrent operation (5%), followed by endoscopic resection with adjuvant medical therapy (30%) and endoscopic dilation (50%). These data support the initial observations and continue to provide value to providers and patients navigating longitudinal decision-making. Level of evidence: 2—prospective cohort study.

AB - The North American Airway Collaborative (NoAAC) previously published a 3-year multi-institutional prospective cohort study showing variation in treatment effectiveness between 3 primary surgical techniques for idiopathic subglottic stenosis (iSGS). In this report, we update these findings to include 5 years of data evaluating treatment effectiveness. Patients in the NoAAC cohort were re-enrolled for 2 additional years and followed using the prespecified published protocol. Consistent with prior data, prospective observation of 487 iSGS patients for 5 years showed treatment effectiveness differed by modality. Cricotracheal resection maintained the lowest rate of recurrent operation (5%), followed by endoscopic resection with adjuvant medical therapy (30%) and endoscopic dilation (50%). These data support the initial observations and continue to provide value to providers and patients navigating longitudinal decision-making. Level of evidence: 2—prospective cohort study.

KW - cricotracheal

KW - dilation

KW - dyspnea

KW - endoscopic resection

KW - iSGS

KW - idiopathic

KW - laryngology

KW - subglottic stenosis

KW - tracheal resection

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85159931382&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85159931382&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/ohn.190

DO - 10.1002/ohn.190

M3 - Article

C2 - 36939627

AN - SCOPUS:85159931382

SN - 0194-5998

VL - 168

SP - 1570

EP - 1575

JO - Otolaryngology - Head and Neck Surgery (United States)

JF - Otolaryngology - Head and Neck Surgery (United States)

IS - 6

ER -

Comparative Treatment Outcomes for Idiopathic Subglottic Stenosis: 5-Year Update

Abstract

Keywords

ASJC Scopus subject areas

Access to Document

Other files and links

Fingerprint

Cite this