Functional outcomes of hybrid hiatal hernia repair

Gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) results in a total healthcare cost of 12.3 billion dollars to the United States annually. GERD is often seen with hiatal hernias. Our study aims to compare short-term functional outcomes and postoperative symptom relief afforded by hiatal hernia repair with transoral incisionless fundoplication (TIF), together known as hybrid repair, to those of hiatal hernia repair with surgical fundoplication (conventional repair). We performed a retrospective chart review on 112 consecutive patients who underwent robot assisted laparoscopic hiatal hernia repair at a community hospital by a single surgeon. We found that the short-term functional results and symptom relief with hybrid repair were no superior to those with conventional repair. We did not find a significant difference between hybrid and conventional repair in terms of in 30 day complications, ER visits or inpatients admissions. The number of patients who were symptomatic at delayed follow-up was not significantly different between both the groups. As such, short-term functional outcomes and symptom relief with hybrid hiatal hernia repair are no superior to those with conventional repair. Therefore, surgical repair of hiatal hernia with surgical fundoplication remains the standard of care until further data is available on long-term outcomes of the hybrid approach.